Score: 9

"Very nice."

submission: .:HMS:. Pursuing Decorum MAC8

date: October 1, 2008

The introduction of the song got me interested right away, which is always a good thing when listening to audio. You had a lot of variety and a very good pace to the song. You even slowed down in some parts and then made it quicken back up again. The only thing about this song that I was hoping for was just one of those really fast, energetic spots. I guess something like a solo or just that place that was really hardcore in a song, if that makes sense at all. >.< Still a very good job though.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 5

"Hmm."

submission: Tomorrow Never Comes

date: October 1, 2008

Nothing too great really, but it wasn't really bad. I guess the biggest problem that I had with it was that it really had no structure whatsoever. It just sounded like a bunch of stuff thrown together all at once and was pretty messy in my opinion. The explosion sounds at the end were kind of cool, but I think you should of ended the song as the last one faded out.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 8

"Pretty cool."

submission: But Who Will Save The City

date: October 1, 2008

This is a pretty cool submission. I wouldn't mind hearing what the song sounded like before you revised it because I'm sure it was a great improvement. This was a powerful submission just as you said in your author comments. I could see it being used in an action filled flash animation or perhaps a scene in a flash game of some sort. It's a fun submission to listen to. Good job.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 7

"Nice job."

submission: Colossus.Ambiance

date: October 1, 2008

I do have to admit that the same repetitive noise over and over got annoying after awhile. I don't think that it's so much of hearing it so many times in a row, because it did fit nicely with the song, but I think it was because it was the same exact thing for the entirety of the song. Perhaps if you changed it up somewhere in the middle of the song that it would of made it a little bit more interesting to listen to and not so boring ot the listeners.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 8

"Nice man."

submission: Boring Instrumental

date: September 28, 2008

I don't think it was too boring, but hey your opinion is your own opinion for a reason. I liked the entire thing actually, but I would have to agree with you on one fact. That this song would of been so much better if you would have included lyrics to it. I think you should think about including them some time and maybe resubmitting them. That's really up to you though. Overall, a pretty good song that probably would be even better with the addition of lyrics.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 6

"Lets see here."

submission: It's Finally Coming

date: September 27, 2008

I think in the beginning it was alright, but it was kind of plain and repetitive. It seemed like something was going to happen or change, but it just never happened really. Then it slowed down, which was different and it did sound kind of weird. After it was done slowing down it just sounded like a whole bunch of things thrown together and it made the submission sound a bit messy. Overall, the whole submission just seemed weird and out of place.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 8

"This was decent."

submission: Shades of Optimism

date: September 26, 2008

Congrats on having your submission being used on a game! The first thing that I thought when I started listening to this song was that it would probably be a good piece of ambient music for some sort of game. I'm sure that it will be used in games in the future. The whole thing was fun to listen to and it was very relaxing. It had a very nice fade out at the end of the song also. Overall you did a pretty good job on the submission.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 8

"Pretty good."

submission: §-Love at First Site-§

date: September 26, 2008

Oh no please don't kill the kitty. :( Oh wait, I really don't care since I'm allergic to cats and my nose is bothering the shit out of me right about now. >:(

Just like you said in your author comments the song was a bit repetitive at times, but not too bad to really hurt the submission as a whole. What a nice description you had to the song in your author comments also. Looks like maybe someone has found true love here? ;) I don't know if the ending of the song really fit with the rest of the song because it kind of makes me think that it's finally ending and the rest of the song makes it seem like it's going to last forever. The it that I'm talking about is the feeling that they are having towards each other obviously. So overall a pretty good submission.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 9

"Good job."

submission: §-Save Me-§

date: September 26, 2008

I thought that the author comments you had to describe the song were very interesting as it's probably not what I would have thought of while listening to this song, but the further it got into the song the more I guess I could see imagining the situation. The song was pretty good and it had a pretty cheerful mood to it, which was the original reason why I was confused why this would be about someone in the need of being saved, but then I thought about what the music may sound like if the person had been given a helping hand and what their mood would then be like. I didn't mind the abrupt ending at the end of the song. It could of had a bit of work, but it didn't hurt the submission too much. Maybe you could of used a fade out or something like a sequence that just sounded good towards the end of the song, which ended on a final note.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~

Score: 9

"Pretty good man."

submission: RGH: High(Way)

date: September 26, 2008

I loved the way it started out with the piano, but I do think the guitar needed to be just a bit louder. The guitar does give the song kind of a dark feeling though, which makes the song interesting because it's not what I would of saw the song being when I first started listening to it. Lyrics might be pretty cool on the song. I don't think they are needed, but they wouldn't hurt either. So if you do put some lyrics on them make sure to check back in with the Review Request Club so we can check it out.

C52

~ Review Request Club ~